Thursday 18 October 2012

Weak, encore

"Your problem is . . ."

She pauses, looking at me reflectively, assessing.
Weighing up all of my thirty three years and finding them wanting.
Alas and alack, my daughter.

"Your problem is that you have never faced any real adversity. And, as a result, you never developed any emotional resilience. No bounce in you. You just crumple at the slightest thing."

This hurts. More than it should. The truth does have a tendency to do that.

I wonder why I am weak.
Why I am one of life's leaners.
Why I am one of life's 'walks-with-a-crutch'-ers.
Overindulged. Not loved enough. Loved too much.
Saw too much. Didn't see enough.
And I'm far too old to keep blaming my parents and their dear caring hearts.
The buck stops here.
With me.

Why, when things go wrong, do I stand with my arms reaching outwards?
Like a trusting, foolish child?
Eternally optimistic, expecting the very earth to have an interest in assisting me.
An enormous great cuckoo in the nest.

And, don't get me wrong, I do believe that being able to ask for help is a good thing.
Just not taken to this extreme.

I wish I could remember who I was before. Was I always so pathetic?
I want to plead my case. To say, "No, you have forgotten. You have forgotten that I wasn't always like this. That it was the adversity that punched everything out of me. THE Adversity. That one time that beat me up and stabbed me in the gut and fried my brain and took everything, including my first daughter. Leaving me flat and shrivelled with no reserves for anything else."

Broken down cars. Schools that insist your child attend them and then won't let her attend as she throws up every morning. Slow moving traffic. Office politics. Money worries. Marital problems.

Those little things that everyone else seems to cope with. Because they don't know any better?

Weak. Weak. Weak. Still like kindling.
But I don't want to start a fire.
Because if I burn away my mother, my husband. What is left?
So I leave those neatly tied bundles of tinder unlit.
Dry.

***

Reuben fell off his ride on this weekend. He fell forward and bumped his forehead on the floor. A huge bruise ensued. I took him to nursery and he cried and screamed and didn't want to be put down. They waved an enormous 'pre existing injuries' form at me. And I panicked. Because I'm scared.

Deep within me, I'm scared that they will be taken from me. Because I'm weak and pathetic.

So I smiled and said, "oh perhaps I'll just take him home."

Because it's safer there. I can lock the doors.

***

I stood in the playground with Jessica.

"It's Jessica!" scream the boys, wailing with delight. "It's Jessica."

She chases them, she keep going. In 'attack mode.' Or so I'm told by the boys.

Cough. Cough. Cough.

I touch her on the arm. I say, "Jessica, do you want to stop?"
And she stops and I cuddle her. She coughs until she is sick.

I ask the teacher if I may please have some wipes from her bag to clean it up. She says, "We can't take her now you know?"

I know. I know.

"Why are we leaving mummy?"

"Because you were sick my darling. I'm sorry."

***

And I need to get some strength. From where, I don't know.

Because there must come a time. There must come an age.
For putting away childish things.
To stop cooing 'cuckoo.'

A time for being strong.

When I was little, my parents were like totem poles holding up the sky.
I was certain of them.

But my children have seen me weeping.
As I whisper, "I'm sorry." into their necks.

But that doesn't cut it.
I need more. I owe them.
But it is a fight. It doesn't come easily to me. Calm. Stability.
Something bovine.
Gentle.
Something.
Not very much like me.

***

Doesn't mean I won't try.

Because I will try.
I'll try harder.
To grow those additional stiffening bones around the spine.
More vertebrae.
Because some of us were born without a sufficiency.
Doesn't mean we can't grow them.

And I want it.
I want strength.
Rings around the trunk.
Thick bark.
A ready smile.
Play dates. Friends.

Not yet.

But I do have.
I have something.
I hope that this is what they remember.
That and the fact that I am fighting.
Not against their sister.
But with her.

And it's something that is easily confused for something else.
It's hard to come by.
But it's all I've got.

Any tips?



24 comments:

  1. O Cath, I'm sorry. So sorry. You ARE strong; I know you dont believe me, but you are. So very strong. People who say things like that clearly have never been hit so hard that they crack and sway but still find the strength to stand.

    And your babies... I know you ache for them and will do all you can for them. Let me know how, from across the great divide, I can help. For now, I'm sending love and hugs...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sending love. Lots and lots and lots of love. I wish I had a tip, but I just don't know. I often find myself right where you are, you just say it so much better than I ever could.
    xo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also wish I had a tip or just . . .something? Anything? That would help. Thinking of you xo

      Delete
  3. Catherine, Nothing could have prepared you for Georgina's death. There is no previous adversity that would have given you resilience. None. No romantic breakup, divorce, betrayal, no other tragedy or death, not even the death of another child could give you the ability to bounce back from her death. That statement is wrong, Catherine.

    The strength to live and love after the death of a child is not like physical strength. If your hands are strong, you can open a jar easily. If your hands are weak, you need help, an opener or such. Mentally and emotionally, strength does not equal easy. It is easy to love your children, all of them. Does that mean you are strong? Reaching out to others when your heart is broken can be so hard and frightening. Does it make you weak because you only do so 4 times this week, not 20? I don't think so. I think the strength it takes to reach out at all is very great.

    I know you feel very weak, broken and uncertain of everything. You are those things, in some ways, at some times, and much more than you want to be or think you should be. But in addition to weak and unsure, you are strong and determined. They exist side-by-side, not as one or the other.

    Sending you love,
    Jill A.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you're right Jill. I try and think of anything that could have prepared me and I can't come up with anything.

      I am uncertain of absolutely everything. But, I think you're right, you can be both weak and strong, at different times, in different fields.

      Delete
  4. What?! Did someone actually say that to you (the quote at the top)? That makes me want to kick some ass (arse).

    Anger....People are free to say what they will about anger being a destructive force--and sometimes it is, not denying that--but I believe that, because human beings cling to our black-and-white thinking, we are prone to say that anger is ALL BAD. But it props me up sometimes. Not always. There are those times when it munches on my soul. Nonetheless, it has fueled me, it has given me the energy to keep going forward when all other sails were flagging--and for that, I'm grateful to it.

    You know, in addition to having parents who are alike in some ways, I think you and I share a certain sensitivity that has, from a young age, been present and which one or both parents have tried to grind out of us. I DO "blame"--or hold responsible, or acknowledge influence, or however you want to put it--my parents for most (not all) of the life lessons of the formative years of my life. I am a product of my parents and environment, after all. There was, no doubt, a lot of love and loveliness....And then again, there are certain aspects from which I would like to distance myself. But I can never separate myself completely because that was my life, that was me--just as THIS, this life without Molly, is me. All of it, in its entirety, is my story. And my upbringing is one of things that makes me ME.

    I've never met you in person, but I get the sense that you have a lot more strength than anyone gives you credit for. Pathetic? Weak? No! That is NOT the truth. Or, if it is, it isn't the the only truth because it's also the case for every single human being on the planet whether they admit it or not. It's not pathetic or weak to be scared. That's just *human*.

    My inner Warrior Woman can be fierce and lately has developed a VERY steely edge, but she sustains me when I'm feeling beaten. She stands guard and shields the softer me when I need it, and at times, goes on the offensive, yes. Protecting, surviving, loudly roaring.

    I will never claim to know you better than you do, EVER, so please tell me if I'm way off base...but I get the sense that you have an inner Warrior Woman, too, and that your WW would like to fire back at anyone who would dare judge you: "Tosser, Wanker, Cow!" (Which I imagine are the British equivalent of "Asshole, Shithead, Bitch"??)

    And if not, my WW would be more than happy to step in temporarily for you, to brandish that sword and shield when the weight feels too heavy for you. That's what friends are for, my love.

    p.s. I'm very sorry that you're stressed. Money, Jessica's school, and marital problems are not "little things." You have a lot on your plate. How can I support you? I want to, in some way, in any way, so please tell me how I can.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh yes it was really said to me. Thank you for making the (arse) concession!

      I love the sound of your inner Warrior Woman. I think I've heard her roaring a couple of times. I do have an inner WW on occasion. Once my BIL said to me, after he'd had a few drinks, that the thing about me was that I was always calm and polite and nice UP to a certain point. Then I do tend to come out with . . . .well, you've pretty much nailed it. I do have to congratulate you on your vernacular English! Wanker is my insult of choice.

      Perhaps we can combine forces. Covering off both continents with our insults!

      My love. You already support me. Far more than you could ever know. xo

      Delete
  5. Catherine,

    I'm just completely enraged by what that woman said to you. Where does she get off? Did she even take a moment to consider the enormity of Georgina's death and the circumstances of Jessica's birth? Not to mention the general challenges of balancing parenting and work and life even under the best conditions!?! How can anyone with such a complete lack of empathy become a professional charged with expressing empathy? What kind of warm-up adversity would have prepared you for raising a daughter born so early while mourning her sister?

    I've already spouted off about grit or spine or spunk or whatever you want to call it on my own blog so I'll keep it short. How in the world can these people not see that it's possible to use up one's supply of grit? Isn't it obvious?

    I think I've also spouted off about the way that the school officials are treating you already but, shouldn't it really be a combination of vomiting and fever that restricts school attendance? I don't think that the other kids are going to catch Jessica's respiratory issues that are a result of pre-term birth.

    Holy shit! I'm so angry at all of these people!

    But you can't really say any of those things, can you? It's that horrible choice between being branded sad and weak v. bitter and crazed. There's really no good way to deal or to be when you've outlived one of your children, is there? Why doesn't anyone understand that?

    Anyway, I'm going to wrap up this rant now. Sending lots of peace and strength to you. Hang in there, Catherine.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is exactly it. I have used up my innately meagre supply of grit. I was born with an insufficiency and now? It's all gone.

      I've tried explaining that to the school but they are convinced that Jessica's pre-term birth has no long lasting repercussions. I'm negotiating with her consultant to write a letter setting them straight.

      And yes you can't say those things. You've described that cross road so perfectly. One way, sad and weak, the other, bitter and crazed. And I don't want to go in either of those directions.

      Thank you Tracy, thank you for understanding xo

      Delete
  6. I'll quote my fellow commenter above " there's really no good way to deal or to be when you've outlived one of your children, is there? Why doesn't anyone understand that?"

    That says I all.

    All I wish is for everyone to be gentle with you...with all of us. Some people have a bone to pick with the world, and when you cross their path...there are bones coming out of your ass, and too many wars could be waged. It's best to avoid them. It's all very exhausting, isn't it? Because its nearly impossible to do so.

    If there's anything you'd like me to do...pick up milk? Call the cable company about a recent over charge? Take out the trash, and freshen the cats pan...I'll do it. Just let me know.

    Sending my love to you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wish that there was more gentleness in the world.

      You're so sweet Veronica. I wish I could return the favour but there is that pesky Atlantic Ocean in the way xo

      Delete
  7. nothing can prepare us for losing a child. i feel the same way sometimes- like it hit me too hard, affected me too much, changed me in too many ways. yet when mothers lose a six, twelve or twenty year old does society expect them to bounce right back? parents never get over losing a child, and that includes babies. you are stronger than you know. incredibly strong.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello CeCe, going to pop over to yours in a moment to see how things are going. I feel that too, that it changed me too much and that other people would judge me for that? x

      Delete
  8. Sorry that you are having such a hard time. For me, I forced myself to leave my comfort zone. I kind of got so used to pretending to be strong that some of it stuck. Going out to work, teaching, was a huge deal but I felt I had to - I had to be the bread winner. Playing in the band was another biggy.

    But then, every now and again I notice that I'm not as good at pretending as I thought I was. I had a ridiculous argument with an irate parent on the yard (in front of other parents) this week. About how her son (aged 6) had cut his hair in my class and what was I going to do about it? I didn't handle it too well and wanted the ground to eat me (or more preferably her). And I find myself being hugely oversensitive about what people say. Even daft throw away remarks can leave me reeling. But then, I'm sure I was like that pre-Emma. But now it is more acute.

    I don't have any advice. And the thing is that I don't think anyone parents perfectly. Throw into the mix having a dead child and the waters become incredibly murky. So sometimes, again for me, the key is not to beat myself up over how I treat my own children.

    Sending love

    Emma's Daddy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh Emma's Daddy. I know what you mean - I think? Eventually you get pushed out of your comfort zone and you have to at least pretend to be strong. I can't be moping about or being over sensitive at work for instance? And, like you, I have to win at LEAST the same amount of bread as my hubs or our house will get re-possessed. So there really isn't any choice in the matter.

      I sometimes find that, when I'm jollying the children along to try and get them to co-operate, I've kind of jollied myself along in the process. If I don't think about it too much.

      Because I've also had those uneasy moments when I realise that I'm not doing quite as good a job as I think I am. For me, it is increasingly manifesting itself in anger. I just feel so cross a lot of the time.

      My mind is boggling as to the argument with the parent in the playground. What could you have done about her son decided to cut his hair in your class. He's six. He presumably knew what he was doing and that he shouldn't have been doing it. At least he cut his OWN hair? What does she expect you to do about it exactly? Encourage it to grow back? Tidy it up for him with a quick snippity snip?!

      I know that I have always been oversensitive. Like you say, it's just more acute. And while people being unkind used to make me cry now it just makes me want to punch their lights out?! I guess that is progress? Not sure if it is a favourable direction but a change is as good as a rest as they say.

      Sending love, I miss your blog and I've been thinking of you and Jill and your dearest Emma this October. She was such a beautiful baby.

      Delete
  9. Oh Catherine. It is a hard place to be. A very wise woman (my therapist for many years) used to ask me "What is good about being like that?" when I came in criticising myself with the proficiency of many years practice. Boy, did I struggle to find an answer for her. But she asked it often enough for me to hear the question and sometimes ask it of myself.

    We are who we are. Some of us feel with an intensity others will never know. Some of us are sensitive to taste or smell or whatever. Some of us live as though life is their very best friend. Some us will find fault in ourselves no matter what others say - good or bad. (Me, I live in the constant expectation of being found out. And not in a good way) We can't be what others want us to be. We can only be ourselves.

    You, Catherine, are an amazing woman. You love your children with a passion. You write with a raw honesty and fragility and beauty that I aspire towards. You are good enough - and in psychology good enough is far better than perfect. That is one of the most valuable things I have ever learned.

    Sending love to you and strength.

    x Louise

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh Louise. Your comment got stuck in my moderation folder. I have comment approval turned on as I live in morbid fear of someone saying something mean. Nobody ever has. I should probably switch it off?

      "What is good about being like that?" is a very good question. A very good question indeed.

      But . . . we are who we are. You're right. I ask myself why I cannot simply switch that internal critic off. But it would appear that, currently, I can't. My husband calls him the evil chairman of the board of Catherine W!

      Thank you so much for your kind words Louise. Good enough is . . . well, good enough and I just need to persuade myself that really is the case.

      And I was so tempted to publish your second comment because it was so beautifully written!

      Catherine xo

      Delete
  10. I can not believe that person said that to you!!! It makes me ill. All these people and what they think of who we are and how we ought to act when they have experienced nothing of our tragedy. The fact that we continue to rise in the morning and parent our children is evidence of the enormous amount of strength it take just to survive after your child has died. No matter if we cry or do not cry in front of our children, I think we would evaluate our actions as being less than optimal because we always want to be more, offer more, parent better. I'm sorry for your struggles. It seems the weight of the pain would force evolutionary vertebral growth just to keep us upright Even when our heads are bent in mourning.

    ReplyDelete
  11. My reaction to this was to ask a similar question to the one posed by Radarofchance's therapist: what is the good of being like that? What is the good of such stern resilience? Really? And why is it a bad thing, to have not faced "real adversity"? To some extent, that is what we should all want, what we should want for our children, for our friends and family? What is the value of adversity? Of toughness? What is it we are avoiding when we want those who suffer to keep it to themselves? You can't be loved - or love - too much and, to my mind at least, the kind of weakness you talk about here is a strength, too. A strength of feeling, of empathy, of presence in the 'real' world of experience, which is not all pretty, not all what we might wish it to be. Sending love.

    ReplyDelete
  12. There's so much in this, but I wanted to just pick out one tiny detail that really touched me:

    "But my children have seen me weeping.
    As I whisper, "I'm sorry." into their necks."

    Me too. And it used to worry me endlessly. I was terrified that I would be damaging Hugo if he saw me upset. So I held it all in, until I burst. Then I chastised myself, a bit like you have here, for being so weak. All I had to do was hold it together everyday until he slept, and THEN I could let it all out - but stupid me couldn't even manage that much.

    I've since changed my mind. It's ok if Hugo sees me sad, I think (in moderation). I want to be honest with him. From the start. I want him to feel that he can express himself in his home, just like I can, just like his Daddy can. I want to teach him that tears are not weak, that they simply show how much I loved his brother. And how sad I am that he is not here.

    I must admit, it's harder to put this into action than I anticipated - my default reaction when I start to cry is to stop the tears as fast as I can... But I'm working on it.

    “There is a sacredness in tears. They are not the mark of weakness, but of power. They speak more eloquently than ten thousand tongues. They are messengers of overwhelming grief... and unspeakable love.”

    Washington Irving.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I come to this late but as always you speak such truth. I am sorry those words were said to you. I truly can't understand how anyone could say them to anyone, it is ridiculous and cruel. We could never be prepared for the loss of our much loved children. Nothing makes it okay or any more understandable.

    I never have any wise words to offer, I do not feel wise. You are however in 'good' company in crying into the necks of your children and apologising though. I have caught myself crying so much lately and Ava's twin has commented a couple of times. She has clearly thought about it as the comments have been at other points. That just makes me feel worse. It makes me feel that I can't even do right for her (we won't go there with Ava). I think Aoife is right though in her comment about tears being sacred and demonstrative of love. We won't harm our children by crying. It is something I am trying to tell myself although it is not going so well at the moment. Being gentle on yourself is so very hard isn't it.

    Wishing for gentle days for you and all of your children, those here on earth and Georgina who soars with the angels. x

    ReplyDelete
  14. It's so hard.

    You should move up here.

    I think we'd get on well IRL, and I think I've got some friends you would love too.

    xxx

    ReplyDelete