Wednesday 28 December 2011

Siblings

Yesterday the W family went to visit my sister and her husband.

Jessica and her dad, my brother in law and his son, went to see the rugby at Twickenham. Jessica was part of a record breaking crowd, the highest ever attendance at an English regular season domestic league game, to see Harlequins play Saracens. I can't decide if she has, subsequently, talked more about the rugby or the bus journey there (her first, a red double decker). I think that public transport is edging out sporting spectacle in her three year old mind. 

My sister and I stayed behind with Reuben. We were playing Kirby's Epic Yarn (which I can highly recommend if you are the computer game playing type) and had an equally epic conversation about parenting styles, the influence and idiosyncrasies of our own parents, how these have formed various aspects of our personalities and our own, previously discussed, parenting or mis-parenting, how we might have influenced one another, how we have communicated and mis-communicated throughout the years. And so on. One of those looping, sustained conversations that occur between people who have known one another for their entire lives. Well, I have known her for her entire life. Prior to that I was mooching about on my own for nearly five years waiting for her to show up. 

And this was interspersed with occasional bouts of shouting and cries of "take me OFF your head you fool! No, no put me back ON!" related to Kirby.

The rugby fans returned. We packed the children up into the car. We said goodbye to my sister and her family and drove home.

I thought, as we drove home in the dark silence, I could have spoken for longer. I would have enjoyed talking for longer. I would have liked playing that computer game for longer. But only with her. Not on my own. Because it wouldn't have been so much fun on my own. 

Without the conversation. Without the faux mad and jostling. 
Because although we are 32 and 28, we aren't really. Not when we're together. We could be 8 and 4 sometimes. We are some weird essential flickering self, composed of many selves. So many that it is incoherent to anyone other than those who saw the infinitesimal progression from one step to the next.

Because there is a depth to a conversation with a sibling (or a sibling equivalent) that there simply isn't with anyone else? Perhaps? It is like reading a webpage absolutely jammed pack full of hyperlinks. Or a book crammed with footnotes. Somebody whose formative years and cultural touchstones are so similar to your own that you can both flick back and forth at speed through your own histories and current life and times. So I say, "you remember that time when I was so sad that I tried to melt myself with one of the small electric fan heaters that Dad gave us even though they were incredibly dangerous and I'm surprised we didn't burn the house down what the hell was he thinking and I think I was just hoping to evaporate myself at that particular time with said dangerous fan heater and I'm never giving either of my children access to a fan heater by the way" and she knows exactly the time that I am referring to. The sadness that I am referring to. Even the fan heater. In fact, that fan heater is probably the mental image that pops into both of our minds when we hear the word fan heater. Because we had the same fan heater. She just wasn't trying to melt herself with hers.

No matter how you try, I don't know if you can really create that kind of sibling bond. It all its deep weird rich annoying loveliness. Generally the longest relationship of your life. If you're lucky. Well, I suppose it would only be lucky if you liked one another and that is certainly not guaranteed. 

It's almost a strange kind of experiment, sibling-hood. One that would not be granted ethical approval. Here - we will take two young(ish) creatures of the same species with a similar genetic inheritance and force them to compete for parental attention and affection in a very limited space (I live in England without substantial financial backing thus forcing me to live in a glorified rabbit hutch and it is often dark and cold, forcing you inside) and see what transpires? Nah, never going to make it past the committee that one.

Like knocking two pebbles together inside a very tiny sea in a very small glass jar. With one or two prevailing tides. Or a couple of moons.

I suspect a twin sibling relationship would stand an even smaller chance of passing ethical scrutiny.

But I don't know. It hurts. And I worry. Jessica could have expected a life long companion in Georgina, someone who would have that fullness of shared knowledge and experience. I don't know what that relationship is like with a brother, if it is different in quality or just the same or purely dependent on the people involved. I've never had a brother. I hope that it is this fact, rather than some inherent sexism on my part, that makes me worry that you can't have that sort of closeness between a brother and a sister. 

I rather hope that Jessica won't mourn Georgina too much. If that doesn't sound odd. That Reuben won't seem less or worse for being younger, for not being her twin, for not being a female, for not being a sister. That he will just be himself and be accepted and loved as such.

Perhaps Jessica herself will never contemplate any of this at all. I kind of hope not. When you have one parent who very rarely seems to reflect on anything (or not that I have any inkling about) and one parent who ruminates from now until kingdom come on the same three small days? Who knows which way that wind will blow? I'm hoping in the opposite direction from me. 

Long may she be more interested in buses. 

I was going to write about parenting, inspired by Aoife's comment on my previous post, but now this is already far too long and it's getting far too late here. I will save my ramblings on that for a later date although, given how this post worked out, perhaps I should save them permanently.

Here's some sisters, I'm nursing a serious obsession with this particular song of theirs.

Can any of you who have brothers or sisters advise? Or no siblings at all? Just interested to hear how it all panned out for you.

18 comments:

  1. I think sibling relationships can be complicated, no matter the sex/age difference. It`s hard to know what Jessica will think - I do know that you`ll be there to support her an answer her questions as best you can. You are a wonderful mother, Catherine.

    I don't know if you know of Tegan and Sara - identical twin singers from Canada - they're great, I think you'd like them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I know nothing of brothers, but I am close with my sisters. And yes, when we are back together we seem to fall into our roles. I'm particularly close to one sister and she knows me well, even parts of me that I don't always like to acknowledge. And I love all the hyperlinks in our life. I suspect if we played a game of association and you said Monopoly, new home, tired, and bassinet, she and I would come up with the same stories.

    K. talks easily about Henry right now, but I wonder how that will change as she grows and understands more and differently. Her relationship with E. seems about right for right now, loving, caring, sharing, hitting, kicking, stay away . . .

    ReplyDelete
  3. "When you have one parent who very rarely seems to reflect on anything (or not that I have any inkling about) and one parent who ruminates from now until kingdom come on the same three small days? Who knows which way that wind will blow? I'm hoping in the opposite direction from me."

    Oh, I hope *not.* The examined life is the one worth living - and I hope your children follow in your remarkable, fascinating, ruminating footsteps. I hope for them "lighter" moments, scattered in, but I vote, "Reflect away. Keep at it."

    The reflection is all wrapped up in the ability to truly live.

    I have no sisters. Two brothers; one I am closer to, and one I am further from. You're right...there is that sibling shorthand that you can't get anywhere else. And when they, like you, have kids and start evaluating childhoods, you both say, "Do you remember that like I do?" Eye-opening.

    How is your little son doing...? Tummy better, I hope?

    Please don't stop reflecting and please don't stop writing about what you think, Catherine W. :)

    Cathy in Missouri

    ReplyDelete
  4. P.S. So much cool music on your blog, too!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow Catherine, what a beautiful and poignant post.
    I am one of five, in the middle. Four girls, then the boy last. I am close to my sisters equally. Also close to my brother (who recently lost his twin boys), but there is a difference in the closeness that I have with my sisters. One of my closest friends is one of two (both girls) and they practically can't stand being in the same space together for more than an hour before they are arguing. I just cannot imagine being like that with any of my siblings. We have our twin boys as well, but they are so incredibly different. They both fought for my attention, with one suffering undiagnosed hydrochephalus until he was five months old. He was a screamer, night and day. The other learned very early that he may as well sit back and wait his turn, and this is the dynamic set up from birth. I think it's just all about dynamics, family order, family loss and maybe just a little bit of astrology thrown in.
    Do keep ruminating. I just so wish you didn't have to and that it was all evident and unfolding before your eyes, in real life. Your two girls alongside each other. Three days can be a lifetime. Your beautiful Georgina. Beautiful Jessica and Rueben. xo

    ReplyDelete
  6. I have 5 siblings - 3 sisters and 2 brothers... And I firmly believe the relationships built are all dependent on the personalities involved. I am closest to number 6 (brother) and number 2 (sister) (I am number 5). But the closeness is very different... With my sister, we talk about everything, share, support, and she's been a pillar of strength to me over these last few months. With my younger brother, we hang out, reminisce - it's more light-hearted. But I value both of those relationships so very much.

    The thing is, I see those relationships as very separate and distinct creatures: I don't get silly drunk with my sister - that's my brother's role - but I don't see her as less because of it. And I don't usually bare my soul to my brother - I'd call my sister for that - but he's not lacking because of it. I suppose in someways, I'm spoiled for choice...

    In all my ramblings, what I'm trying to say is that, maybe Jessica won't connect the loss of her sister with the survival of Reuben - maybe she'll have her relationship with him, that is distinct, and then maybe her relationship with Georgina will be likewise - a separate entity.

    One of my nieces, who is now 4, has really taken to Seamus. It's strange. Out of my 9 nieces and nephews, she is the one who still talks about him all the time. I gave her some photos of him to keep, and she proudly produces them whenever she gets the chance - if my sister has dinner guests, or even at the hairdressers - whenever she gets the opportunity. She feels special to have a "cousin in the sky". It's lovely. She took it all in her stride (better than most adults in some ways) asks lots of questions, and doesn't flinch before talking about Seamus. It's an everyday conversation for her - no taboos, no off-limits. She knows what happened is very sad, but she's not damaged by it. It seems Seamus has gained a very special status with her, and it warms my heart to see it.

    I suppose, in my clumsy way, what I'm trying to say is, Martha sees it for what it is - a terrible loss - but she treats it like a gain. Seamus is a very special, unique cousin that not many people have. And for that, she loves to talk about him. I suspect, that will change as she grows, but for now, it's a lovely relationship to see.

    For Jessica, her relationship with Georgina might be likewise... but I suppose only time will tell. I'm sure you'll handle it beautifully when the time comes to explain it to her.

    Sorry for the essay... And bring on the post about parenting... very intrigued to hear your thoughts. xx

    ReplyDelete
  7. Aoife,

    I love Martha!

    Please, Martha, stay like this. This kind of heart, this kind of real. You are a rare kid.

    There is definitely no need to apologize for an "essay" like that one...warmed me right to my toes.

    Cathy in Missouri

    ReplyDelete
  8. I absolutely LOVED this post. I have been thinking a lot about siblings lately, on Kaia's behalf. I have no idea if she will ever have a sibling beyond Aidan. He will always be her brother but since he sits on the shelf in the living room, he's not going to be able to do any of the things that big brothers are suppose to.

    Personally, I have a brother and no sisters. I will say that as much as I loved my little brother as a child, I wanted a twin sister. (I know if Jessica wishes for the same thing it will just rip your heart out). I thought a twin sister would be an awesome built in best friend. But then, I know other women who have sisters who they fight with constantly so maybe it all just depends on personality. As adults I would say I'm 'close' with my brother in that when we are together we can talk about almost anything, yet I could go many weeks without seeing him even though we live in the same city.

    One thing I will say about having a brother is that as a teenager and young adult, I felt much more comfortable around boys of my own age than some of my friends who only had sisters did. It was easier for me to befriend them and talk with them because I knew what interested them from listening to my brother. I had quite a few 'guy' friends growing up and it helped me to be more self-assured to know that guys have many of the same worries as girls do around the opposite sex.

    Thanks for the thought provoking post.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you Monique. I will have to look out Teagan and Sara.

    Sara - like you, I know nothing of brothers. Perhaps that is why this troubles me! J. says the same to Reuben, especially when he cries, she shouts "go AWAY Bay Oo-ben!"

    Cathy - this is such an interesting aspect, the 'do you remember it like I do?' thread. I often find that we don't and there is a rich seam of conversation to be mined, in the discrepancies between our memories. We can make a conversation out of anything, my sister and I! Little R is much better now thank you. You are very kind. And I'm glad you like the music, this song has been played to bits in my house in recent days.

    Kate -Interestingly my mother is also the third in a family of five, four girls and a younger boy. Her sibling relationships are quite interesting which I think has fuelled my fascination with brothers and sisters in general. You're so right, it is dynamics. So interesting how the interaction between your boys seems to have almost formed them a little. I wonder if Jessica would have been a slightly different person had Georgina survived? And I'm pretty sure astrology plays its part to! Some mysterious, unquantifiable thing comes into play, definitely.

    Aoife - I've just left TWO essays back at your blog! And I love reading your comments, please don't ever apologise for them. I hope Jessica sees Georgina in a similar light to that in which Seamus is viewed by Martha, as something special, unique, a gain. Interestingly my eldest niece talks about Georgina the most of anyone in the family probably. In a similar fashion to your Martha. Sadly, her own oldest brother, Thomas, died at birth and she often chats about him and Georgina. She asked me once if her babies would die and that was very heartbreaking indeed. But she doesn't cry over her lost brother and cousin, she just seems to mention them quite naturally and to . . . consider them? Not quite the right word. They are at times of more interest to her, at others, of less. Probably the closest I have to a glimmer of how Jessica might feel in the future I suppose. She's 8 now and was only 5 when the twins were born so it's been *interesting* seeing her come to grips with it.

    I'm sure you're right about the relationships between siblings. They are so strongly tied up in individual personalities and you can't really make sweeping generalisations. I think that the emphasis on the twin relationship, the sister relationship, is entirely within my own mind and I've just got to be careful that it doesn't somehow transmit itself to my children. And because I have only one sibling, I have this idea that one brother or sister must (or could) be all the world. Which is far from the case. Different people for different facets. Like a strange, turning, interlocking jigsaw or somesuch?

    Emily - As you have with Kaia, I know that I also considered whether Jessica would have any living siblings at all. And I know that I think far more about siblings than she will for many years to come. But it is hard not to debate these things on their behalf.

    It WILL rip my heart out if she wants a twin sister but it is very possible that she may express that wish at some point in the future. I'd better brace myself I guess! And yes, there are siblings who really don't get along. I suppose Georgina's death kind of glossed over that possibility in my mind. Perhaps they would have disliked one another intensely? I'll just never know.

    I think it's very true what you say about being comfortable around the opposite sex. I did not have any close male friends between the ages of about 6 and 16, although I had plenty as a very young child and as an older teenager, and I think that was because I did not have the ease that having a brother would have given me. Hope that your lovely Kaia is well xo

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think it's different with brothers, but also that it depends on the people involved & probably on lots of other things I don't even know to consider. And since I don't have sisters, I'm not sure what the differences really are.

    I can tell you that I love having a little (well, younger - he's now much bigger than I am) brother. We were close growing up, and in high school, and then ended up at the same college. We can roll our eyes in unison at some of the things our parents say, and we have shared memories aplenty. I miss that closeness sometimes now that we're turning into middle-aged adults and living on different coasts.

    But then I found myself emailing him late at night on Christmas Eve because while I didn't want to wake his sleeping wife, it feels off somehow, and still strange not to talk to him last thing on Christmas Eve night. And he called just last night, and we talked and talked, and could have talked longer - our conversation filled with hyperlinks, and I realize the closeness is mostly still there, if buried, and what I miss is him.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Such a thought-provoking post and something I've considered on and off over the years.

    I definitely think it has a lot more to do with personality than just gender, or age gap, or any of that stuff. In my own family, I only have a younger brother. We have never been close and we barely speak now. Perhaps once or twice a year. We share nothing but biology really.

    This would make me despair for my own two--a brother and sister combo--if it also weren't for my husband's family. He comes from a family of six kids and he's closest to two of his sisters, even though he does have a brother. And one of the sisters is seven years older than he is; yet some of the other sisters closer to his age don't figure as prominently in his life.

    I also have a friend from university who has a younger brother and she has remained close with him their whole lives...both are in their late 30s/early 40s now.

    I close my eyes and wish so much that my kids will somehow get along, enjoy each other's company, and will continue to do so well into their adult years. It's like I walk around with fingers crossed and wishing on evening stars. After their father and I are gone one day, they'll only have each other as immediate family.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I'm the youngest of 6: four older sisters and one older brother. They all still live close to each other (from birth into their 40's and 50's). They all ran a software business together for years. Spent every day and Sundays together, raised families together, and stayed close.

    I studied literature, traveled, and ran off to the West Coast, 1000 miles away.

    I'm not close with my siblings. But they are all very close to each other.

    I have a friend who had a twin sister who died shortly after birth, similar to your girls. They were born very, very early: my friend was only about two pounds. She didn't know about her twin until she was an adult (!), and then her grandmother accidentally told her. Once she learned about her twin who had died, everything in her life seemed to make sense and come together. It's like she had always known about her, there had always been a hole in her world, but no one had ever said. Once it was named, her world came together.

    When she talked to me about it for the first time, pretty early on, before we were close, she was very matter-of-fact about it. It doesn't seem painful per se - just part of her. Her connection is still there, and there is a sense of sacredness about it.

    I don't know if her connection is tinged with the sadness or anger of grief as much as the unknown, and unknowable alternate world. She wonders what her life would be like now had her twin lived. She wonders why her twin died, and not her. Her sibling relationship is still very much there.

    It will be interesting to observe how Jessica grows in to her life being a twin, and the ways that she perceives and experiences Georgina.

    Thank you for sharing your story and perceptions on this path. Much love and light to you all.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Lovely post, as always Catherine. I wonder a lot about this too. If it is any comfort, I have a younger brother - 5 years my junior - and while we were sworn enemies for much for our childhoods, there was a point when I was about 16 when I suddenly realised that it was actually pretty cool to have a brother, and we bonded over music and daggy TV shows. Now, he really is a rock in my life - we don't have the same long conversations my sister and I do, but we hang out and swap music and he's been there for me during some of my hardest moments. In the hours after Z was born, when I had to have another CT scan to check my internal bleeding , he came with me and held my hand as long as he could. It is as everyone above has said, all about the dynamic, but it is important to know that even sibling relationships with a rough start can get much better. I'm sure Jessica and Reuben will be tremendously important to one another in all kinds of ways, and that while Georgina isn't here, that they know they have another sister, and that they can somehow find a special spot for their connection with her in their lives. Sending you all lots of good wishes for 2012. xxxx h

    ReplyDelete
  14. I wonder all the time what Clio will think of George. Eventually she will probably come to the inevitable conclusion that had George lived she would never have existed and what kind of mind fuck is that?

    I tend to think she will think of him in more abstract terms, "My parents had another baby before me. He died" and not necessarily as "I had a brother but he died." I prefer it that way, I think.

    But a twin, well, that is a different thing completely, isn't it? There is a connection there that I don't understand and never will. Then again, I don't think it is possible for our children to think of the loss of their siblings with the same intensity that we do. They are growing up with a dead sibling as something normal in their lives.

    Have you ever listened to First Aid Kit? Also a sister duo and pretty amazing. This song is one I listened to on repeat after George died, even though it really didn't have anything to do with death in the physical sense. But the idea of a ghost town really spoke (speaks) to me, mostly because I have my own ghost town that I often return to.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2BKUjnyf8uY

    ReplyDelete
  15. Catherine, a lovely post.

    I'm the eldest of two sisters too and my daughter is without her only sister and will grow up with brothers only. So, I've wondered about the mysteries of brother/sister relationships, having not experienced it myself and grieved for my daughter's lost relationship with a same sex sibling. There is an irony though. When I was pregnant with Emma, I hoped she would be a boy ... purely because I thought that was best for Lucy. I had no preference at all but in terms of family fit I was aware that I was making my feisty, firecracker, melodramatic, creative little girl into the middle child and I thought that allowing her to keep her "only girl" status would cushion her against the loss of "youngest" status. Now, of course, we're in the hinterland "not the only girl but the only living girl" and I mourn for the thing I never looked for.

    I am close with my sister - cat fight, hair pulling (not recently!), and all. I actually see the relationship I have with my sister being similar to the relationship that Ben and Lucy have - when it's good, it's very, very good and when it's bad, they need separating! So, not based solely on gender but a complex mix of personality, genes, birth order, gifts, skills ... ad infinitum ... and Toby seems to be universally adored as "The boy who lived" (no lightning scar though) -they seem to forgive him a lot of his toddler mischief because he came to them (and us) alive.

    ReplyDelete
  16. It makes me tremendously sad to think Hope and Juliet won't have what my sister and I have. I think I'm done having babies, too. So there is no real chance to give Juliet a sister. My sister has a daughter, so I hope she and Juliet can be close. Not that we can't be close to brothers, as I am close to mine, but it is different with my sister for sure.
    Our losses are so layered. This is just another one of them. Huge sigh.
    xo

    ReplyDelete
  17. You, my dear, are a sweetheart. I have both a brother and a sister, and while I am closer to my sister, that is more a function of the fact that we are not-quite-three years apart, and my brother and I are nine years apart - much bigger gap/stage of life thing happening there. I can tell you that at 1 and 5, my kids WORSHIP each other. Anika loves Sam to distraction. She wants to marry him. She wants him to come with her everywhere. She is SO fiercely proud of him and loyal to him it's ridiculous. And Sam cannot get enough of her. She's the first person he asks for when he gets up from his nap (he knows we go pick her up from school then). He will follow her around everywhere. They are making up games together, laughing together...creating that shared history that you speak of. I think it's different than it would be between sisters, for sure. But I don't think it's worse.

    xoxo.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Sorry i am so late to this...

    My first thoughts are... No, i don't think she will mourn her sister as hard. Kids are so amazingly resiliant and innocent. Georgina's death will impact her for sure, she will feel close to her, she will miss her, but her youth... I think it protects her from the same kind of grief we feel as mothers... At least this is what I have watched in Caelan. That boy blows me away as I am sure Jessica will as she gets older.

    As for the sibling thing. I have both. I was very close to my brother as we were growing up, we were the two youngest... Things were great until he got messed up in drugs during his mid teens and they really hurt him and his ability to communicate and function. We've had a some really rough moments and he's doing okay now but we will never have that closeness again (self preservation on my part) but we are okay... Strangely enough, my eldest sister and I never got along when we were younger but we are now best friends. I mean really, she is my closest friend and someone whom I couldn't live without.

    She will be just fine and they will have a beautful, loud, loving, bitchy, rough housing, huggy, awesome relationship... and you will be the referee... :)

    ReplyDelete